Suggestions by @kjamal

Finn Wolfhard

as James in Peter and the Starcatchers

Score: +1

Jonah Hill

as Slank in Peter and the Starcatchers

Score: +1

Neil Patrick Harris

as Leonard Aster in Peter and the Starcatchers

Score: +1

Vanessa Kirby

as Black Stache in Peter and the Starcatchers

Score: +2

Hannah Rae

as Molly in Peter and the Starcatchers

Score: +1

Julian Dennison

as Peter Pan in Peter and the Starcatchers

Score: +1

Sam Corlett

as Eugene in Tangled (Live Action Disney Remake)

Score: -8

Gavin Leatherwood

as Eugene in Tangled (Live Action Disney Remake)

Score: -8

Miranda Otto

as Mother Gothel in Tangled (Live Action Disney Remake)

Score: -1

Keanu Reeves

as Namor in Marvel Phase 4

Score: -3

Noëlle Renée Bercy

as Tiana in The Princess and the Frog

Score: -14