Suggestions by @kittyscissorpaws

W. Earl Brown

as Joey Drew in Bendy and the Ink Machine

Score: +3

Erica Lindbeck

as Allison Angel in Bendy and the Ink Machine

Score: +2

Elizabeth Olsen

as Evil Alice Angel in Bendy and the Ink Machine

Score: +4

Todd Haberkorn

as Sammy Lawrence in Bendy and the Ink Machine

Score: +2

Christian Bale

as Henry Stein in Bendy and the Ink Machine

Score: +5

Jill Harris

as Alice Angel in Bendy and the Ink Machine

Score: +5

Erica Mendez

as Alice Angel in Bendy and the Ink Machine

Score: +4

Troy Baker

as Boris in Bendy and the Ink Machine

Score: +1

Max Casella

as Bendy in Bendy and the Ink Machine

Score: -1

Angelica Hale

as Zelda in Super Smash Bros.: The Series

Score: +1

Don Darryl Rivera

as Travis in Hazbin Hotel/ Helluva Boss

Score: +3

Mark Hamill

as Vox in Hazbin Hotel/ Helluva Boss

Score: +4

Xander Mobus

as Additional Voices in Hazbin Hotel/ Helluva Boss

Score: +7

Maxwell Atoms

as Additional Voices in Hazbin Hotel/ Helluva Boss

Score: +3

Vivienne Medrano

as Additional Voices in Hazbin Hotel/ Helluva Boss

Score: +5

Elsie Lovelock

as Charlie in Hazbin Hotel/ Helluva Boss

Score: +11

William Andrew Stamper

as Sir Pentious in Hazbin Hotel/ Helluva Boss

Score: +2

Brock Baker

as Stolas in Hazbin Hotel/ Helluva Boss

Score: +3

Laurence Fishburne

as Valentino in Hazbin Hotel/ Helluva Boss

Score: +2

Erica Lindbeck

as Loona in Hazbin Hotel/ Helluva Boss

Score: +12