Suggestions by @keyshawnbess

Nick Nolte

as Martin Riggs in Lethal Weapon 1977-1988.

Score: +4

Harrison Ford

as Martin Riggs in Lethal Weapon 1977-1988.

Score: +3

Sylvester Stallone

as Martin Riggs in Lethal Weapon 1977-1988.

Score: +4

Stephen Lang

as Martin Riggs in Lethal Weapon 1987 alternate cast

Score: +3

Steve Railsback

as Mr Joshua in Lethal Weapon 1987 alternate cast

Score: +2

Mark Hamil

as Will Hunting in Good Will Hunting (1977)

Score: +3

Brian Keith

as Mr Robinson in The graduate 1967 (alternate)

Score: +1

Ava Gardner

as Mrs Robinson in The graduate 1967 (alternate)

Score: +2

Jack Palance

as Mr Robinson in The graduate 1967 (alternate)

Score: +1

Natalie Wood

as Elaine Robinson in The graduate 1967 (alternate)

Score: +1

Candace Bergen

as Elaine Robinson in The graduate 1967 (alternate)

Score: +1

George Hamilton

as Benjamin Braddock in The graduate 1967 (alternate)

Score: +1

Anthony Perkins

as Benjamin Braddock in The graduate 1967 (alternate)

Score: +1

Warren Beatty

as Benjamin Braddock in The graduate 1967 (alternate)

Score: +1

George Peppard

as Benjamin Braddock in The graduate 1967 (alternate)

Score: +1

Harrison Ford

as Benjamin Braddock in The graduate 1967 (alternate)

Score: +1

Burt Ward

as Benjamin Braddock in The graduate 1967 (alternate)

Score: +1

Charles Grodin

as Benjamin Braddock in The graduate 1967 (alternate)

Score: +1

Harvey Keitel

as Benjamin Braddock in The graduate 1967 (alternate)

Score: +1

Jack Nicholson

as Benjamin Braddock in The graduate 1967 (alternate)

Score: +1