Suggestions by @kennethmiller2

Rosemary Harris

as Martha Miller in Brothers and sister

Score: +1

Elizabeth Olsen

as Emma Miller in Brothers and sister

Score: +1

Chris Evans

as Derek Miller in Brothers and sister

Score: +1

Chris Hemsworth

as Derek Miller in Brothers and sister

Score: +1

Larenz Tate

as Matthew Miller in Brothers and sister

Score: +1

Tobey Maguire

as Johnny Miller in Brothers and sister

Score: +1

Anna Kendrick

as Beverly Marsh in Here We Go Again

Score: +1

Anna Kendrick

as Beverly Marsh (adult) in It

Score: -1

John Krasinski

as Director in Sony's Peter's Story Of 2014

Score: +1

Anna Kendrick

as Selena Tun in Sony's Peter's Story Of 2014

Score: +1

Tobey Maguire

as Peter Addams in Sony's Peter's Story Of 2014

Score: +1

Ken Kirzinger

as Jason Voorhees in Evil Dead: No Way Home

Score: 0

Bill Skarsgård

as Michael Myers in Evil Dead: No Way Home

Score: +1

Willem Dafoe

as Freddy Krueger in Evil Dead: No Way Home

Score: 0

Benedict Cumberbatch

as Pinhead in Evil Dead: No Way Home

Score: +1

Cameron Monaghan

as Pennywise The Clown in Evil Dead: No Way Home

Score: -1

Tobey Maguire

as Bill Denbrough in Evil Dead: No Way Home

Score: +2

Mackenzie Foy

as Nancy Thompson in Evil Dead: No Way Home

Score: +1

Miranda Cosgrove

as Kirsty Cotton in Evil Dead: No Way Home

Score: +1

Timothée Chalamet

as Andy Barclay in Evil Dead: No Way Home

Score: +1