Suggestions by @kennethmiller

Annette O'Toole

as Charlotte in The Devil All The Time 1997

Score: +1

Val Kilmer

as Preston Teagardin in The Devil All The Time 1997

Score: +1

Hugh Jackman

as Deputy Lee Bodecker in The Devil All The Time 1997

Score: +1

Michael Madsen

as Carl in The Devil All The Time 1997

Score: +1

Patricia Arquette

as Sandy in The Devil All The Time 1997

Score: +1

Richard Thomas

as Willard Russell in The Devil All The Time 1997

Score: +2

Tobey Maguire

as Arvin Russell in The Devil All The Time 1997

Score: +1

Michael Madsen

as Carl in The Devil All The Time 1997

Score: +1

Patricia Arquette

as Sandy in The Devil All The Time 1997

Score: +1

Kristen Stewart

as Charlotte in The Devil All The Time 1997

Score: +1

Zachary Gordon

as Arvin 9 year old in The Devil All The Time 1997

Score: +1

Jay Ryan

as Preston Teagardin in The Devil All The Time 1997

Score: +1

Jake Gyllenhaal

as Lee Bodecker in The Devil All The Time 1997

Score: +1

Henry Cavill

as Willard Russell in The Devil All The Time 1997

Score: +1

Tobey Maguire

as Arvin Russell in The Devil All The Time 1997

Score: 0

Kenneth Dejoan Miller

as Miles Morales in Spider-Man 4

Score: +2

Tobey Maguire

as Peter Parker in Spider-Man 4

Score: +7

Robert Pattinson

as Cowboy in The Warriors remake

Score: +2

Isaiah Mustafa

as Snow in The Warriors remake

Score: +2

Mackenzie Foy

as Mercy in The Warriors remake

Score: +1