Suggestions by @kalish

Brenton Thwaites

as Dick Grayson in Best Live Action Batman Actors

Score: +5

Chris O'Donnell

as Dick Grayson in Best Live Action Batman Actors

Score: +3

Burt Ward

as Dick Grayson in Best Live Action Batman Actors

Score: +2

Robin Lord Taylor

as Penguin in Best Live Action Batman Actors

Score: +3

Colin Farrell

as Penguin in Best Live Action Batman Actors

Score: +4

Danny DeVito

as Penguin in Best Live Action Batman Actors

Score: +3

Burgess Meredith

as Penguin in Best Live Action Batman Actors

Score: +5

Cory Michael Smith

as The Riddler in Best Live Action Batman Actors

Score: +2

Paul Dano

as The Riddler in Best Live Action Batman Actors

Score: +1

Jim Carrey

as The Riddler in Best Live Action Batman Actors

Score: -1

Frank Gorshin

as The Riddler in Best Live Action Batman Actors

Score: +5

Camren Bicondova

as Selina Kyle in Best Live Action Batman Actors

Score: +1

Zoë Kravitz

as Selina Kyle in Best Live Action Batman Actors

Score: +1

Anne Hathaway

as Selina Kyle in Best Live Action Batman Actors

Score: +4

Halle Berry

as Selina Kyle in Best Live Action Batman Actors

Score: -2

Lee Meriwether

as Selina Kyle in Best Live Action Batman Actors

Score: +7

Michelle Pfeiffer

as Selina Kyle in Best Live Action Batman Actors

Score: 0

Eartha Kitt

as Selina Kyle in Best Live Action Batman Actors

Score: +1

Julie Newmar

as Selina Kyle in Best Live Action Batman Actors

Score: +2

Cameron Monaghan

as Joker in Best Live Action Batman Actors

Score: +2