Suggestions by @jw1

Emmy Rossum

as Thursday in The wives

Score: 0

Sasha Luss

as Hannah in The wives

Score: +2

Anya Taylor-Joy

as Regina in The wives

Score: 0

Ryan Guzman

as Gus in If You Only Knew

Score: +2

Daniel Henney

as Owen in If You Only Knew

Score: +2

Zoey Deutch

as Emmanuelle in If You Only Knew

Score: +2

Matt Bomer

as Leo in If You Only Knew

Score: -1

Blake Lively

as Rachel in If You Only Knew

Score: -1

Adria Arjona

as Ana-Sofia in If You Only Knew

Score: +2

Ana de Armas

as Ana-Sofia in If You Only Knew

Score: 0

Gal Gadot

as Ana-Sofia in If You Only Knew

Score: -1

Harry Shum Jr.

as Owen in If You Only Knew

Score: -1

Joseph Morgan

as Leo in If You Only Knew

Score: -1

Theo James

as Leo in If You Only Knew

Score: -1

Anne Hathaway

as Jenny in If You Only Knew

Score: -2

Claire Holt

as Rachel in If You Only Knew

Score: 0

Rachel McAdams

as Rachel in If You Only Knew

Score: -2

Theo James

as Adam in If You Only Knew

Score: +1

Evan Rachel Wood

as Emmanuelle in If You Only Knew

Score: -1

Scott Eastwood

as Leo in If You Only Knew

Score: +2