Suggestions by @jvpirate

Sophie Turner

as Beatrice Portinari in Dante's Inferno

Score: 0

Robert Pattinson

as Dante Alighieri in Dante's Inferno

Score: 0

Hugh Jackman

as Lucifer in Dante’s Inferno Animation Remake

Score: +1

Kurt Russell

as God in Dante’s Inferno Animation Remake

Score: +1

Maisie Williams

as Beatrice in Dante’s Inferno Animation Remake

Score: +1

Sabrina Carpenter

as Lili Von Shtupp in Blazing Saddles

Score: +1

Florence Pugh

as Lili Von Shtupp in Blazing Saddles

Score: +1

Gerard Butler

as Marcadé in Love’s Labour’s Lost

Score: +1

Isabela Merced

as Jaquenetta in Love’s Labour’s Lost

Score: +1

Aimee Lou Wood

as Morgan Le Fey in Quentin Tarantino's King Arthur

Score: +1

Ethan Hawke

as Lucifer in Dante’s Inferno Animation Remake

Score: +1

Liam Neeson

as Virgil in Dante’s Inferno Animation Remake

Score: +1

Alex Pettyfer

as Dante Alighieri in Dante’s Inferno Animation Remake

Score: +1

Bailee Madison

as Beatrice in Dante’s Inferno Animation Remake

Score: +1

Nathan Lane

as King Herod in Jesus Christ Superstar

Score: +1

Ethan Peck

as Caiaphas in Jesus Christ Superstar

Score: +1

Melissa Barrera

as Fantine in Les Miserables (Revival)

Score: +1

Asha Banks

as Cosette in Les Miserables (Revival)

Score: +1

Mckenna Grace

as Eponine in Les Miserables (Revival)

Score: +1

Anna Kendrick

as Fantine in Les Miserables Live

Score: +1