Suggestions by @justanillusion

Maude Apatow

as Maddy Lavoy in Five Survive

Score: -2

Willa Holland

as Stella Bloom in Lovelight Farms

Score: -4

Evan Peters

as Luka Peters in Lovelight Farms

Score: -6

Sydney Sweeney

as Harper Porter in Lovelight Farms

Score: +2

Sofia Carson

as Evelyn St. James in Lovelight Farms

Score: -6

Sophia Anne Caruso

as Nova Porter in Lovelight Farms

Score: 0

Sabrina Carpenter

as Nessa Porter in Lovelight Farms

Score: +2

David Harbour

as Dane Jones in Lovelight Farms

Score: +2

Alberto Rosende

as Caleb Alvarez in Lovelight Farms

Score: +2

Joe Keery

as Charlie Milford in Lovelight Farms

Score: +2

Melissa McBride

as Ms. Beatrice in Lovelight Farms

Score: +1

Katelyn Nacon

as Layla Dupree in Lovelight Farms

Score: +1

Jedidiah Goodacre

as Beckett Porter in Lovelight Farms

Score: -9

Meg Donnelly

as Macy in Crave

Score: -3

Dacre Montgomery

as Cal Kane in The Fine Print

Score: 0

Joseph Quinn

as Rowan Kane in The Fine Print

Score: -19

Joe Keery

as Benton James Kesslet in November 9

Score: -14

Halston Sage

as Jordyn in November 9

Score: +1

Nick Robinson

as Theodore in November 9

Score: +2

Calahan Skogman

as Malcom in The Love Hypothesis

Score: -16