Suggestions by @jurassicjohnny

Antonio Banderas

as Meta Knight in The Super Smash Bros. Movie

Score: +1

Jason Bateman

as Fox McCloud in Who should voice Fox in the Mario Galaxy movie?

Score: +1

Hajime Wakai

as Pikmin in Super Mario Galaxy (NCU)

Score: +1

Jason Bateman

as Fox McCloud in Super Mario Galaxy (NCU)

Score: +1

Ben Campbell

as King K. Rool in The Donkey Kong country

Score: +1

Ed Skudder

as R.O.B in Full Super Smash Bros. Roster Fancast

Score: +1

Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles III

as Best Review in Best & Worst of The Angry Video Game Nerd

Score: +2

Eric Bauza

as Diddy Kong in Super Mario Galaxy

Score: +1

Little Red Hood

as Best Review in Best & Worst of The Angry Video Game Nerd

Score: +2

Hong Kong 97

as Best Review in Best & Worst of The Angry Video Game Nerd

Score: +2

Elizabeth Gillies

as Pauline in Super Mario Galaxy

Score: +1

Kristen Schaal

as Toadette in Super Mario Galaxy

Score: +1

Tim Curry

as King Boo in Super Mario Galaxy

Score: +1

Michael-Leon Wooley

as Piranha Plant in Super Mario Galaxy

Score: +1

Katsuyuki Konishi

as Rayquaza in Super Smash Bros. Brawl (NCU)

Score: +2

Michael-Leon Wooley

as Petey Piranha in Super Smash Bros. Brawl (NCU)

Score: +2

Duon

as Duon in Super Smash Bros. Brawl (NCU)

Score: +2

Galleom

as Galleom in Super Smash Bros. Brawl (NCU)

Score: +1

Bullet Bill

as Koopa Troop in Super Smash Bros. Brawl (NCU)

Score: +2

Antonio Banderas

as Meta Knight in Mario and Sonic: Dimensional Heroes Adventures

Score: +1