Suggestions by @jtnolan

Henry Cavill

as Michael Carpenter in Dresden Files

Score: -1

Matthew Broderick

as Father Anthony Forthill in Dresden Files

Score: +4

Emilia Clarke

as Karrin Murphy in Dresden Files

Score: -2

Joe Keery

as Harry Dresden in Dresden Files

Score: -7

Jennifer Aniston

as Muriel Rush in Live in Front of a Studio Audience: Too Close for Comfort

Score: +1

Bryan Cranston

as Henry Rush in Live in Front of a Studio Audience: Too Close for Comfort

Score: 0

Anna Kendrick

as Judy Haynes in White Christmas Remake 1954

Score: +1

Helena Bonham Carter

as Betty Haynes in White Christmas Remake 1954

Score: 0

Pierce Brosnan

as Major General Tom Waverly in White Christmas Remake 1954

Score: +1

Johnny Depp

as Major General Tom Waverly in White Christmas Remake 1954

Score: +1

Zac Efron

as Phil Davis in White Christmas Remake 1954

Score: +1

Hugh Jackman

as Bob Wallace in White Christmas Remake 1954

Score: +1

James Horner

as Composer in Batman: The World's Greatest Detective

Score: 0

Kevin Smith

as Writer in Batman: The World's Greatest Detective

Score: +1

Alfonso Cuarón

as Director in Batman: The World's Greatest Detective

Score: +1

Sterling K. Brown

as lucius Fox in Batman: The World's Greatest Detective

Score: 0

Paul Rudd

as The Penguin in Batman: The World's Greatest Detective

Score: +1

Jonah Hill

as The Penguin in Batman: The World's Greatest Detective

Score: +1

Tom Hanks

as Carmine Falcone in Batman: The World's Greatest Detective

Score: 0

Sean Bean

as James Gordon in Batman: The World's Greatest Detective

Score: +1