Suggestions by @joshparker

Daniel Gilchrist

as Peter Mayhew in I've Got a Bad Feeling About This

Score: +2

Dan Fogler

as Francis Ford Coppola in I've Got a Bad Feeling About This

Score: +1

Luke Macfarlane

as Lt. Cmdr. Chal Avok in Star Trek: Legacy

Score: +1

Jessica Clark

as Lt. Grace Palermo in Star Trek: Legacy

Score: +1

Matt Berry

as Planchet in The Three Musketeers

Score: +1

Troy Kotsur

as Grimaud in The Three Musketeers

Score: +1

Eugenio Derbez

as Nicomo Cosca in The First Law Trilogy

Score: +1

Sterling K. Brown

as Hiram Carter in Hap & Leonard

Score: +1

Wanda Sykes

as MeeMaw Carter in Hap & Leonard

Score: +1

Bryan tyree henry

as Rev. Hamil Fitzgerald in Hap & Leonard

Score: +1

Eriq La Salle

as Lt. Marvin Hanson in Hap & Leonard

Score: +1

Tessa Thompson

as Florida Grange in Hap & Leonard

Score: +1

Gina Carano

as Angel in Hap & Leonard

Score: +2

Wyatt Russell

as Howard in Hap & Leonard

Score: +2

Jasper Pääkkönen

as Soldier in Hap & Leonard

Score: +1

Louis Cancelmi

as Paco in Hap & Leonard

Score: +1

Paul Walter Hauser

as Chub in Hap & Leonard

Score: +2

Alexander Skarsgård

as Howard in Hap & Leonard

Score: -1

Christina Ricci

as Trudy Fawst in Hap & Leonard

Score: +1

Brad Pitt

as Soldier in Hap & Leonard

Score: -1