Suggestions by @josephleanos
573 suggestions
Seth Rogen
as Donkey Kong in Super Mario Bros
Score: +2
Anya Taylor-Joy
as Princess Toadstool in Super Mario Bros
Score: +3
Fred Armisen
as Cranky Kong in Super Mario Bros
Score: +3
Kevin Michael Richardson
as Kamek in Super Mario Bros
Score: +2
Jack Black
as Bowser in Super Mario Bros
Score: +2
Charlie Day
as Luigi in Super Mario Bros
Score: +2
Chris Pratt
as Mario in Super Mario Bros
Score: +2
Ponyo
as Cutest Girl in Cutest Anime Characters
Score: +3
Sacha Baron Cohen
as Richard Hunt in The Muppet Man (Jim Henson BioPic)
Score: +2
Elaina Keyes
as Penelope in SML (Live on Stage)
Score: +2
Ariana Grande
as Glinda in Wicked Movie (story removed)
Score: +1
Cynthia Erivo
as Elphaba Thropp in Wicked Movie (story removed)
Score: 0
Elaina Keyes
as Karen in SML (Live on Stage)
Score: +2
Lovell Stanton
as Charleyyy in SML (Live on Stage)
Score: +1
Lance Thirtyacre
as Jackie Chu in SML (Live on Stage)
Score: +1
Lance Thirtyacre
as Mr. Goodman in SML (Live on Stage)
Score: +1
Logan Thirtyacre
as Junior in SML (Live on Stage)
Score: +1
Tress MacNeille
as Dot Warner in Animaniacs (Reboot)
Score: +6
Rob Paulsen
as Yakko Warner in Animaniacs (Reboot)
Score: +3
Jess Harnell
as Wakko Warner in Animaniacs (Reboot)
Score: +3