Suggestions by @josephlawson

Rick Moranis

as Professor Poopypants in Captain Underpants 1990s

Score: +1

Chris Farley

as Captain Underpants and Mr. Benjamin "Benny" Krupp in Captain Underpants 1990s

Score: +7

Jonathan Taylor Thomas

as Harold Hutchins in Captain Underpants 1990s

Score: +3

Merlin Santana

as George Beard in Captain Underpants 1990s

Score: +1

Cooper Barnes

as Cooper Barnes in Snl Old School Years

Score: +2

Martin Mull

as Martin Mull in Snl Old School Years

Score: +1

Chelsea Peretti

as Chelsea Peretti in Snl Old School Years

Score: +1

Jason Mewes

as Jason Mewes in Snl Old School Years

Score: +1

Bridgit Mendler

as Jane Curtin in Snl Old School Years

Score: +1

Matt Bennett

as Matt Bennett in Snl Old School Years

Score: +1

Kate Micucci

as Kate Micucci in Snl Old School Years

Score: +1

Kel Mitchell

as Kel Mitchell in Snl Old School Years

Score: +1

Drake Bell

as Drake Bell in Snl Old School Years

Score: +1

Shane Harper

as Shane Harper in Snl Old School Years

Score: +1

Dan Fogler

as Dan Fogler in Snl Old School Years

Score: +1

Anders Holm

as Anders Holm in Snl Old School Years

Score: +1

Donald Pleasence

as Professor Stone in Wild Cats Movie 80s

Score: +1

Dolph Lundgren

as Attica in Wild Cats Movie 80s

Score: +1

Jean-Claude Van Damme

as Artemis in Wild Cats Movie 80s

Score: +1

Marc Singer

as Zachary Forbes in Wild Cats Movie 80s

Score: +1