Suggestions by @josephlawson

Jackie Gleason

as Papa Elf in Elf 1970s

Score: -3

Danny Bonaduce

as Michael Hobbs in Elf 1970s

Score: +2

Katharine Hepburn

as Emily Hobbs in Elf 1970s

Score: +4

Laraine Newman

as Jovie in Elf 1970s

Score: +1

George C. Scott

as Walter Hobbs in Elf 1970s

Score: -1

Steve Martin

as Buddy Hobbs, aka "Buddy the Elf" in Elf 1970s

Score: -3

Anthony Michael Hall

as Spider-Man in The Avengers (1987)

Score: +1

Clint Eastwood

as Eddie Brock As Venom in Spiderman 1960s

Score: -2

Sally Field

as Gwen Stacy in Spiderman 1960s

Score: 0

Tor Johnson

as The Rhino in Spiderman 1960s

Score: +1

Buddy Ebsen

as J Jonah Jameson in Spiderman 1960s

Score: +1

Vincent Price

as Norman Osborn as the green goblin in Spiderman 1960s

Score: -1

Natalie Wood

as Mary Jane Watson in Spiderman 1960s

Score: -1

Dennis Hopper

as Flash Thompson in Spiderman 1960s

Score: -1

Jack Nicholson

as Harry Osborn in Spiderman 1960s

Score: +1

Joan Crawford

as Aunt May in Spiderman 1960s

Score: -2

George Burns

as Uncle Ben in Spiderman 1960s

Score: +1

Steve McQueen

as Spiderman As Peter Parker in Spiderman 1960s

Score: -1

Phil Hartman

as Shemp in The Three Stooges 80s

Score: +2

Sam Kinison

as Curly in The Three Stooges 80s

Score: +1