Suggestions by @jonrivera

Gabriella Baldacchino

as Flavia in Legend of Destruction

Score: +1

Shira Haas

as Young Mary in The Passion of the Christ (Sequel)

Score: +2

Zoe Saldaña

as Lunja in Dreamworks' Noah

Score: +1

Mandy Moore

as Shamar in Dreamworks' Noah

Score: +1

Simon Kassianides

as Simon Peter in The Gospel of Luke

Score: +1

Joseph Fiennes

as Jesus in The Gospel of Luke

Score: +1

Frank Langella

as Tubal-cain in Dreamworks' Noah

Score: +1

America Ferrera

as Eve in Dreamworks' Adam and Eve

Score: +3

Rosario Dawson

as Eve in Dreamworks' Adam and Eve

Score: +4

Paloma Baeza

as Sita in Dreamworks' Noah

Score: +1

Indira Varma

as Sita in Dreamworks' Noah

Score: +1

Idris Elba

as Ham in Dreamworks' Noah

Score: +1

Kevin Alejandro

as Shem in Dreamworks' Noah

Score: +1

Lin-Manuel Miranda

as Japheth in Dreamworks' Noah

Score: +1

Rita Moreno

as Naamah in Dreamworks' Noah

Score: +1

Temuera Morrison

as Noah in Dreamworks' Noah

Score: +2

Adrien Brody

as Abel in Dreamworks' Adam and Eve

Score: -1

Anika Noni Rose

as Eve in Dreamworks' Adam and Eve

Score: +1

Lifehouse

as Adam in Dreamworks' Adam and Eve

Score: -1

Mido Hamada

as Bar Abba in The Last Week of the Christ (miniseries)

Score: +2