Suggestions by @joker

Mateus Ward

as Jason Todd in Matt Reeves: The Batman Trilogy

Score: -5

Ben Foster

as Conor McGregor in Pretty Boy Floyd

Score: +1

Joshua Bassett

as Brady in Teen Beach Movie (2023)

Score: +4

Giancarlo Esposito

as Det. William Somerset in Se7en (2015)

Score: +1

Bryan Cranston

as John Doe in Se7en (2015)

Score: +2

Joaquin Phoenix

as John Doe in Se7en (2015)

Score: +3

Jake Gyllenhaal

as Det. David Mills in Se7en (2015)

Score: +2

Aaron Paul

as Det. David Mills in Se7en (2015)

Score: +3

Aaron Paul

as Billy Costigan in The Departed (Remake)

Score: +2

Jeffrey Wright

as Gus Fring in Breaking Bad

Score: +4

Adam Sandler

as Jimmy Conway in The Safdie Brothers’ Goodfellas

Score: 0

Buddy Duress

as Tommy DeVito in The Safdie Brothers’ Goodfellas

Score: +1

Robert Pattinson

as Henry Hill in The Safdie Brothers’ Goodfellas

Score: +3

Dacre Montgomery

as Billy Costigan in The Departed

Score: -1

Jon Bernthal

as Sgt. Dignam in The Departed

Score: +6

Bryan Cranston

as Commissioner James Gordon in The Dark Knight Trilogy

Score: +3

Bryan Cranston

as Norman Osborn in Spider-Man

Score: +1

Mark Hamill

as Otto Octavius in Spider-Man

Score: +1