Suggestions by @johnawalker

Claudia Lee

as Donatella in Caraval

Score: -36

Victoria Justice

as Scarlett in Caraval

Score: -30

Sarah Dugdale

as Ianthe in A Court of Thorns and Roses

Score: -3

Carla Woodcock

as Feyre Archeron in A Court of Thorns and Roses

Score: -7

Logan Lerman

as The Ghost in The Cruel Prince

Score: -22

Zoey Deutch

as Taryn Duarte in The Cruel Prince

Score: -11

Mitchell Hope

as Matt Millis in Starcrossed

Score: +1

Matthew Noszka

as Hector Delos in Starcrossed

Score: +5

Tyler Hoechlin

as Lucas Delos in Starcrossed

Score: +1

Steven R. McQueen

as Jason Delos in Starcrossed

Score: +1

Alexander Ludwig

as Hector Delos in Starcrossed

Score: +1

Brenton Thwaites

as Jason Delos in Starcrossed

Score: +3

Jude Law

as Castor Delos in Starcrossed

Score: +1

Jason Bateman

as Jerry Hamilton in Starcrossed

Score: +1

Ginnifer Goodwin

as Kate in Starcrossed

Score: +1

Carla Gugino

as Noel Delos in Starcrossed

Score: +1

Emilia Clarke

as Pandora Delos in Starcrossed

Score: +1

Victoria Park

as Claire Aoki in Starcrossed

Score: +2

Selena Gomez

as Ariadne Delos in Starcrossed

Score: 0

Camren Bicondova

as Ariadne Delos in Starcrossed

Score: 0