Suggestions by @joeyhalgren

Adelaide Kane

as Donna Troy in Avengers vs. Justice League

Score: -1

Emilia Clarke

as Sue Storm in Avengers vs. Justice League

Score: -2

Daniel Craig

as Victor Von Doom in Avengers vs. Justice League

Score: +3

Zac Efron

as Nightwing in Avengers vs. Justice League

Score: -1

Kellen Goff

as Freddy Fazbear in Five Nights At Freddy's

Score: +1

Micheal Doonan

as Micheal Afton in Five Nights At Freddy's

Score: +1

Benedict Cumberbatch

as William Afton in Five Nights At Freddy's

Score: -6

Alan Cumming

as Doctor Doom in Fantastic Four

Score: -10

Nicholas Hamilton

as Human Torch in Fantastic Four

Score: -3

Torrance Coombs

as The Thing in Fantastic Four

Score: -5

Emilia Clarke

as Invisible Woman in Fantastic Four

Score: -1

John Krasinski

as Mr. Fantastic in Fantastic Four

Score: +14