Suggestions by @joeyhalgren
253 suggestions
Norman Reedus
as Michael Myers in Welcome to the Bates Motel
Score: 0
Alden Ehrenreich
as Detective Hoffman in Welcome to the Bates Motel
Score: 0
Asa Butterfield
as Damian Wayne in DC Universe Reboot - Fan Casting
Score: -6
Common
as John Stewart in DC Universe Reboot - Fan Casting
Score: -2
Grant Gustin
as Peter Parker in Ultimate Spider Man(story removed)
Score: -4
Jared Gilmore
as Jason Todd in Batman TV
Score: -1
Noah Schnapp
as Tim Drake in Batman TV
Score: -1
Jackson Robert Scott
as Damian Wayne in Batman TV
Score: 0
Noah Schnapp
as Jason Todd in Batman TV
Score: -4
Cynthia Addai-Robinson
as Amanda Waller in Batman TV
Score: +2
Peyton List
as Betty Lou Anderson in Fantastic Four
Score: 0
Torrance Coombs
as Jacob Grimm II in Fantastic Four
Score: +1
Ethan Peck
as Batman in Injustice(story removed)
Score: +1
Armie Hammer
as Aquaman in Injustice(story removed)
Score: 0
Grant Gustin
as Flash in Injustice(story removed)
Score: -1
Brendon Urie
as Evan Hansen in Dear Evan Hansen(story removed)
Score: -1
Brendon Urie
as Carnage in Marvel Cinematic Universe(story removed)
Score: 0
Peyton Kennedy
as Barbra Gordon in Batman TV
Score: -1
Anna Kendrick
as Harleen Quinzel in Batman TV
Score: -1
Adelaide Kane
as Selina Kyle in Batman TV
Score: -2