Suggestions by @jlencino

Seth Rogen

as Kenny in Scream

Score: +3

Juno Temple

as Lambert in Alien

Score: +4

Rafe Spall

as Ash in Alien

Score: 0

Rami Malek

as Kane in Alien

Score: +5

Michael Shannon

as Dallas in Alien

Score: 0

Lily James

as Ellen Ripley in Alien

Score: 0

David Oyelowo

as Parker in Alien

Score: +1

Lucy Hale

as Beth in Friday The 13th (Horror Cinematic Universe)

Score: 0

Evan Peters

as Mike in Friday The 13th (Horror Cinematic Universe)

Score: +3

Awkwafina

as Eleanor in Friday The 13th (Horror Cinematic Universe)

Score: 0

Henry Cavill

as Eric in Friday The 13th (Horror Cinematic Universe)

Score: +3

Lucas Hedges

as Joey tribbiani in Friends

Score: -2

Will Poulter

as Joey tribbiani in Friends

Score: -2

Zoey Deutch

as Monica geller bing in Friends

Score: +3

Zoe Kazan

as Monica geller bing in Friends

Score: -5

Ruth Negga

as Monica geller bing in Friends

Score: -4

Michelle Trachtenberg

as Monica geller bing in Friends

Score: -2

Tessa Thompson

as Monica geller bing in Friends

Score: -1

Leonardo DiCaprio

as Richard burke in Friends

Score: 0

Himesh Patel

as Ross geller in Friends

Score: -2