Suggestions by @jimwoehr

Stellan Skarsgård

as Robert Nightengale in Alan Wake 1-2

Score: +2

Chris Hemsworth

as Ilmo Koskela in Alan Wake 1-2

Score: +1

Liam Hemsworth

as Jaakko Koskela in Alan Wake 1-2

Score: +1

David Harewood

as Mr. Door in Alan Wake 1-2

Score: +1

Shawn Ashmore

as Tim Breaker in Alan Wake 1-2

Score: +1

Olivia Swann

as Saga Anderson in Alan Wake 1-2

Score: +2

Jake Gyllenhaal

as Alan Wake in Alan Wake 1-2

Score: +1

Dean Norris

as Robert Nightengale in Alan Wake 1-2

Score: +2

Todd Stashwick

as Thomas Zane in Alan Wake 1-2

Score: +1

Kristian Bruun

as Barry Wheeler in Alan Wake 1-2

Score: +1

Christoph Waltz

as Emil Hartman in Alan Wake 1-2

Score: +2

Julia Stiles

as Alice Wake in Alan Wake 1-2

Score: -1

Bradley Cooper

as Alan Wake in Alan Wake 1-2

Score: +1

Guy Pearce

as Alan Wake in Alan Wake 1-2

Score: -1

Milo Ventimiglia

as Alan Wake in Alan Wake 1-2

Score: +1

Paul Giamatti

as Thompson in The Adventures of TinTin Live Action

Score: 0

Paul Giamatti

as Rastapopoulos in The Adventures of TinTin Live Action

Score: +3

Geoffrey Rush

as Rastapopoulos in The Adventures of TinTin Live Action

Score: +1

Stanley Tucci

as Rastapopoulos in The Adventures of TinTin Live Action

Score: +1