Suggestions by @jillianmaria

Sadie Sink

as Arianthe in From Sea to Star

Score: +1

Emilia Jones

as Maya in From Sea to Star

Score: +2

Thay Bergamim

as Maya in From Sea to Star

Score: +1

Emilia Jones

as Maya in From Sea to Star

Score: +1

Isa Briones

as Nadine in Marked

Score: +1

Luca Hollestelle

as Penelope in Marked

Score: +1

Quintessa Swindell

as Regan Pierce in Ashwood Grove

Score: +1

Chloë Grace Moretz

as Isobel in A Colder Home

Score: +1

Conchita Campbell

as Selena Woods in Ashwood Grove

Score: +1

Aimee Lou Wood

as Selena Woods in Ashwood Grove

Score: +1

Holly Earl

as Kristen in Ashwood Grove

Score: +1

Isa Briones

as Kristen in Ashwood Grove

Score: +1

Victoria Pedretti

as Mila in Flickering

Score: +1

Courtney Bowman

as Wren in Flickering

Score: +1

Sigourney Weaver

as Rosemary in Spellbound

Score: +2

Katy Secombe

as Rosemary in Spellbound

Score: +1

Geena Davis

as Rosemary in Spellbound

Score: +1

Chloe Perrin

as Eloise in Spellbound

Score: +1

Rihanna Quinn

as Eloise in Spellbound

Score: 0

Jérémie Laheurte

as William in Spellbound

Score: +3