Suggestions by @jgrim

Robin Atkin Downes

as Doomsday in DC Extended Universe -- Infamia (Destruction of DCEU)

Score: +1

Yahya Abdul-Mateen II

as David Kane in DC Extended Universe -- Infamia (Destruction of DCEU)

Score: +1

Ciarán Hinds

as Steppenwolf in DC Extended Universe -- Infamia (Destruction of DCEU)

Score: -2

David Corenswet

as Clark Kent (New Timeline) in DC Extended Universe -- Infamia (Destruction of DCEU)

Score: +2

Steven R. McQueen

as Nightwing in Batwoman (Season 2)

Score: 0

Ruby Rose

as Batwomen in Batwoman (Season 2)

Score: +1

Maggie Q

as Proxima Midnight in Secret Wars

Score: 0

Diego Boneta

as 2099 Spiderman in Earth 616

Score: +1

Demetrius Grosse

as War machine in Earth 616

Score: +1

Henry Zaga

as Sunspot in Earth 616

Score: +1

Kelsey Grammer

as Beast in Earth 616

Score: +1

Élodie Yung

as Elektra in Earth 616

Score: +1

Jake Gyllenhaal

as Mysterio in Earth 616

Score: +1

Jason Isaacs

as Green goblin in Earth 616

Score: +1

Ian McKellen

as Magneto in Earth 616

Score: +1

Caleb McLaughlin

as Miles morales in Earth 616

Score: +2

Charlie Cox

as Daredevil in Earth 616

Score: +1

Terry Crews

as Luke cage in Earth 616

Score: +1

Justin Hartley

as Iron fist in Earth 616

Score: +1