Suggestions by @jemmaross

Peter O'Toole

as Wart in Super Mario Bros 2

Score: +1

Frank Welker

as Yoshi in Super Mario Bros 2

Score: +1

Jason Alexander

as Toad in Super Mario Bros 2

Score: +1

Erika Henningsen

as Princess Peach in Super Mario Bros 2

Score: +2

Peter MacNicol

as Luigi in Super Mario Bros 2

Score: +2

Dorian Harewood

as Mario in Super Mario Bros 2

Score: +2

Eric Shonk

as Nick Glasper in Cynophobia

Score: +1

Kayli Mills

as Roxy Stones in Cynophobia

Score: +1

Joe Zieja

as Josh Quinton in Cynophobia

Score: +1

Reba Buhr

as Chelsea Lauren in Cynophobia

Score: +1

Bryson Baugus

as Zach Burns in Cynophobia

Score: +2

Kaiji Tang

as Delray Martinez in Cynophobia

Score: +1

Edward Bosco

as Lucifer in ZOOPHOBIA (Tv Series)

Score: +1

Kayli Mills

as Vanexa Pierce in ZOOPHOBIA (Tv Series)

Score: +3

Christopher Judge

as Paimon in Hellish Darkness season 1

Score: +1

Tim Curry

as Paimon in Hellish Darkness season 1

Score: +1

Jason LaShea

as Paimon in Hellish Darkness season 1

Score: +1

Jonathan Freeman

as Paimon in Hellish Darkness season 1

Score: +1

Charles Dance

as Paimon in Hellish Darkness season 1

Score: +1

Lady Gaga

as Lilith in Hellish Darkness season 1

Score: +1