Suggestions by @jebens1

Lexi Underwood

as Jenna Rolan in Be More Chill

Sabrina Carpenter

as Brooke Lohst in Be More Chill

Peyton List

as Chloe Valentine in Be More Chill

Payton list

as Chloe Valentine in Be More Chill

Haley Tju

as Christine Canigula in Be More Chill

Frankie A. Rodriguez

as Michael Mell in Be More Chill

Darren Criss

as Squip in Be More Chill

Finn Wolfhard

as Jermey Heere in Be More Chill

Anthony Ramos

as Rocky 3 in Starlight Express

Zendaya

as Rocky 2 in Starlight Express

Jaden Smith

as Rocky 1 in Starlight Express

Queen Latifah

as Memphis Belle in Starlight Express

Billy Porter

as Electra in Starlight Express

Idris Elba

as Flat Top in Starlight Express

Rebel Wilson

as Ashley in Starlight Express

Kimiko Glenn

as Buffy in Starlight Express

Amber Riley

as Duvay in Starlight Express

Jack McBrayer

as C.B in Starlight Express

James Corden

as Dustin in Starlight Express

Hailee Steinfeld

as Pearl in Starlight Express