Suggestions by @jazzyjayne23
875 suggestions
Carey Mulligan
as Audrey Tindall/ Shelby Miller in American Horror Story Recast
Imogen Poots
as Audrey Tindall/ Shelby Miller in American Horror Story Recast
Jon Heder
as Jeff Pfister in American Horror Story Recast
Jay Baruchel
as Jeff Pfister in American Horror Story Recast
Michael Cera
as Jeff Pfister in American Horror Story Recast
Jake Borelli
as Mr. Malcolm Gallant in American Horror Story Recast
Robert Sheehan
as Mr. Malcolm Gallant in American Horror Story Recast
Ezra Miller
as Mr. Malcolm Gallant in American Horror Story Recast
Frances McDormand
as The Butcher/ Agnes Mary Winstead in American Horror Story Recast
Glenn Close
as The Butcher/ Agnes Mary Winstead in American Horror Story Recast
Julianne Moore
as The Butcher/ Agnes Mary Winstead in American Horror Story Recast
Jamie Lee Curtis
as Bebe Babbitt in American Horror Story Recast
Catherine O'Hara
as Bebe Babbitt in American Horror Story Recast
Sissy Spacek
as Bebe Babbitt in American Horror Story Recast
Joan Gregson
as Mama Polk in American Horror Story Recast
Lin Shaye
as Mama Polk in American Horror Story Recast
Bonnie Aarons
as Mama Polk in American Horror Story Recast
Halle Berry
as Ramona Royale in American Horror Story Recast
Jada Pinkett Smith
as Ramona Royale in American Horror Story Recast
Gabrielle Union
as Ramona Royale in American Horror Story Recast