Suggestions by @jayminotjamie

Samara Weaving

as Black Cat in The Spectacular Spider-Man 2

Score: +2

Denzel Washington

as Jefferson Davis in The Spectacular Spider-Man 2

Score: +1

Nadji Jeter

as Miles Morales in The Spectacular Spider-Man 2

Score: +1

Frances McDormand

as Aunt May in The Spectacular Spider-Man 2

Score: +1

Katherine McNamara

as Mary Jane Watson in The Spectacular Spider-Man 2

Score: +1

Skyler Samuels

as Gwen Stacy in The Spectacular Spider-Man 2

Score: +1

Jonah Hauer-King

as Harry Osborne in The Spectacular Spider-Man 2

Score: +1

Charlie Rowe

as Spider-Man in The Spectacular Spider-Man 2

Score: -1

Mister Fantastic (Reed Richards)

as Peter's New Boss in The Spectacular Spider-Man 2

Score: +1

Spoiler

as Peter's New Boss in The Spectacular Spider-Man 2

Score: +1

Caleb Emery

as Kenny McFarlane in The Spectacular Spider-Man

Score: +1

Benjamin Wallfisch

as Composer in The Spectacular Spider-Man

Score: +1

Michael Giacchino

as Composer in The Spectacular Spider-Man

Score: +1

David F. Sandberg

as Director in The Spectacular Spider-Man

Score: +2

Caleb Emery

as Kenny McFarlane in The Spectacular Spider-Man

Score: +1

Skyler Samuels

as Gwen Stacy in The Spectacular Spider-Man

Score: +2

Noah Centineo

as Flash Thompson in The Spectacular Spider-Man

Score: +1

J.K. Simmons

as J. Jonah Jameson in The Spectacular Spider-Man

Score: +1

Katherine McNamara

as Mary Jane Watson in The Spectacular Spider-Man

Score: +2

Harrison Ford

as Captain George Stacy in The Spectacular Spider-Man

Score: +1