Suggestions by @jasonadams1

Tobey Maguire

as Spider-Man in Doctor Strange Multiverse of Madness

Score: +2

Rachel McAdams

as Christine Palmer in Doctor Strange Multiverse of Madness

Score: +1

Michael Stuhlbarg

as Nicodemus West in Doctor Strange Multiverse of Madness

Score: +1

Xochitl Gomez

as America Chavez in Doctor Strange Multiverse of Madness

Score: +1

Benedict Wong

as Wong in Doctor Strange Multiverse of Madness

Score: +1

Chiwetel Ejiofor

as Karl Mordo in Doctor Strange Multiverse of Madness

Score: +1

Elizabeth Olsen

as Wanda Maximoff in Doctor Strange Multiverse of Madness

Score: +1

Benedict Cumberbatch

as Doctor Strange in Doctor Strange Multiverse of Madness

Score: +1

Michael Douglas

as Ares in Aquaman (1971)

Score: +1

Jeff Altman

as Weather Wizard in The Flash (1971)

Score: +2

Lyle Waggoner

as Steve Trevor in Aquaman (1971)

Score: +1

Shirley MacLaine

as Queen Mera in Aquaman (1971)

Score: +1

Lynda Carter

as Wonder Woman in Aquaman (1971)

Score: +1

Sean Connery

as Deadshot in Batman (1971)

Score: +1

Michael Gough

as Dr. Hugo Strange in Batman (1971)

Score: +1

Ann-Margret

as Poison Ivy in Batman (1971)

Score: +1

Walter Slezak

as Clock King in Batman (1971)

Score: -1

Victor Buono

as King Tut in Batman (1971)

Score: +1

Anthony Perkins

as Scarecrow in Batman (1971)

Score: +1

Vincent Price

as Egghead in Batman (1971)

Score: +1