Suggestions by @japemanx

Jaden Smith

as Pietro McGillacuddy in Left Handed Slugger

Score: +1

Barack Obama

as Peck McGillacuddy in Left Handed Slugger

Score: +1

Michael McKean

as Police Captain Roger Morgan-Hinder in Left Handed Slugger

Score: +1

Rico Rodriguez

as Clark Benedetto in Left Handed Slugger

Score: +1

Eugene Mirman

as Vice President Borrigan Backo in Left Handed Slugger

Score: +1

Evgeniya Gromova

as First Lady Kalinda Brosnan in Left Handed Slugger

Score: +1

Doug E. Doug

as President Doug Brosnan in Left Handed Slugger

Score: +1

Ayo Edebiri

as Rhonda Lore in Left Handed Slugger

Score: +1

Griffin Newman

as Speed Goman in Left Handed Slugger

Score: +1

Chloe Fineman

as Chloe Markowitz in Left Handed Slugger

Score: +1

Alex Ross Perry

as Seth Jabonowitz in Left Handed Slugger

Score: +1

Jon Gabrus

as Casey Leech in Left Handed Slugger

Score: +1

Nish Kumar

as Brock Romesh in Left Handed Slugger

Score: +1

Kensington Tallman

as Gundun Cork in Left Handed Slugger

Score: +1

Miles Wei

as Jon Peters in Idiosyncratic Imbeciles

Score: +1

Jeffrey Wright

as Rothchild "Ripper" MacNee in Idiosyncratic Imbeciles

Score: +1

Jon Gabrus

as Robert Evans in Idiosyncratic Imbeciles

Score: +1

Iman Vellani

as Gaspara Rex in Idiosyncratic Imbeciles

Score: +1

Nish Kumar

as "Pa" Dohinder Dorkas in Idiosyncratic Imbeciles

Score: +1

Dennis Boutsikaris

as Mitch Effery in Idiosyncratic Imbeciles

Score: +1