Suggestions by @jakewilson1

Jeremy Allen White

as Dr. Mark Williams in Creature from the Black Lagoon (Remake)

Score: +1

Jon Berthnal

as Dr. Edwin Thompson in Creature from the Black Lagoon (Remake)

Score: +1

Matthew Broderick

as Dr. David Reed in Creature from the Black Lagoon (Remake)

Score: +1

Rick Baker

as Make-up Artist in Creature from the Black Lagoon (Remake)

Score: +1

Harrison Ford

as Jim Cunningham in Donnie Darko (1981)

Score: +1

Patrick Swayze

as Frank The Rabbit in Donnie Darko (1981)

Score: +1

John Cusack

as Frank The Rabbit/Frank Anderson in Donnie Darko (1991)

Score: +1

John Goodman

as Eddie Darko in Donnie Darko (1991)

Score: +1

Johnny Depp

as Donnie Darko in Donnie Darko (1991)

Score: +1

John Belushi

as Harry in Home Alone (1980)

Score: +1

Al Pacino

as Iron Monger in Marvel Cinematic Universe (1980s)

Score: +1

Arnold Schwarzenegger

as Ronan The Accuser in Marvel Cinematic Universe (1980s)

Score: +1

Chevy Chase

as Shooter McGavin in Happy Gilmore (1986)

Score: +1

Eddie Murphy

as Matheson in Pineapple Express (1980s)

Score: +1

Chevy Chase

as Private Miller in Pineapple Express (1980s)

Score: +1

Jack Nicholson

as Ted Jones in Pineapple Express (1980s)

Score: +1

Shane Gillis

as Dale Denton in Pineapple Express (2028)

Score: +1

Ted Danson

as Ted Jones in Pineapple Express (1998)

Score: +3

Paul Newman

as Future Terminator in The Terminator (1974)

Score: 0

Jeff Bridges

as Matt in The Terminator (1974)

Score: +1