Suggestions by @jakewilson1

Brock Peters

as Marvin in Sam Peckinpah's Pulp Fiction

Score: +1

Ben Johnson

as The Wolf in Sam Peckinpah's Pulp Fiction

Score: +1

Warren Oates

as Captain Koons in Sam Peckinpah's Pulp Fiction

Score: +1

Bob Dylan

as Pumpkin in Sam Peckinpah's Pulp Fiction

Score: +1

Bo Hopkins

as Zed in Sam Peckinpah's Pulp Fiction

Score: +1

Franklyn Ajaye

as Jules Winnfield in Sam Peckinpah's Pulp Fiction

Score: +1

Kris Kristofferson

as Vincent Vega in Sam Peckinpah's Pulp Fiction

Score: +1

James Caan

as Butch Coolidge in Sam Peckinpah's Pulp Fiction

Score: +1

James Caan

as Vincent Vega in Sam Peckinpah's Pulp Fiction

Score: -1

Bo Hopkins

as Wendell in Sam Peckinpah's No Country For Old Men

Score: +2

Kris Kristofferson

as Llewelyn Moss in Sam Peckinpah's No Country For Old Men

Score: +2

Robert Ryan

as El Paso Sheriff in Sam Peckinpah's No Country For Old Men

Score: +2

William Holden

as Ed Tom Bell in Sam Peckinpah's No Country For Old Men

Score: +2

Dennis Hopper

as Carson Wells in Sam Peckinpah's No Country For Old Men

Score: +2

Burt Young

as Man Who Hires Wells in Sam Peckinpah's No Country For Old Men

Score: +2

Ernest Borgnine

as Gas Station Proprietor in Sam Peckinpah's No Country For Old Men

Score: +2

Al Lettieri

as Anton Chigurh in Sam Peckinpah's No Country For Old Men

Score: +2

Robert Duvall

as Rick Flagg in Sam Peckinpah's Suicide Squad (1975)

Score: +1

Charlie Sheen

as Stu Macher in Scream (1986 - 2013)

Score: +3

Alexander Skarsgård

as Sergeant Hulka in Stripes (2001)

Score: +1