Suggestions by @jakewilson1

Johnny Depp

as Donnie Darko in Donnie Darko (1991)

Score: 0

Ryan Reynolds

as Jim Cunningham in Donnie Darko (2021)

Score: +1

Andrew Garfield

as Elvis Costello in The Replacements

Score: 0

Josh Hutcherson

as Bob Mould in The Replacements

Score: +1

Finn Wolfhard

as Paul Westerburg in The Replacements

Score: +1

Lee Marvin

as Jack Welker in Breaking Bad (1970's)

Score: +1

Steve McQueen

as Jesse Pinkman in What if the Breaking Bad Universe was made in the 50s early 60s

Score: +1

Christopher Walken

as Tobias Hawthorne in The Inheritance Games

Score: -4

Leonardo DiCaprio

as an American photojournalist in Christopher Nolan's Apocalypse Now

Score: +1

Cilian Murphy

as Colonel Walter Kurtz in Christopher Nolan's Apocalypse Now

Score: +2

Christian Bale

as U.S. Army Captain Benjamin Willard in Christopher Nolan's Apocalypse Now

Score: +1

Chris Pratt

as Lieutenant Colonel Bill Kilgore in Apocalypse Now 1979 Remake

Score: -1

Woody Harrelson

as Colonel Walter E. Kurtz in Apocalypse Now 1979 Remake

Score: +2

Al Pacino

as Sergeant "Animal Mother" in Full Metal Jacket (1977)

Score: 0

Leonardo DiCaprio

as Larry Dimmick / Mr. White in Martin Scorsese's Reservoir Dogs

Score: +1

Henry Cavill

as Mr Maroon in Reservoir Dogs 2 New Job

Score: +1

James Cagney

as Mr. White in Reservoir Dogs (1942)

Score: +1