Suggestions by @jaderead

Julian Grey

as James Gordon Jr. in Batman: City of Strange

Score: +1

Anson Mount

as Batman in Batman: City of Strange

Score: +1

Charlie Heaton

as Robin (Current Robin) in Batman: City of Strange

Score: +1

Michael B. Jordan

as Robin in Batman: City of Strange

Score: +1

Kit Connor

as Robin (Hugo Strange creation) in Batman: City of Strange

Score: +1

Gary Busey

as Joker Test in Batman: City of Strange

Score: +1

Domhnall Gleeson

as The Joker (Hugo Strange creation) in Batman: City of Strange

Score: +1

Guy Pearce

as Mr. Freeze in Batman: City of Strange

Score: +1

Giancarlo Esposito

as Hugo Strange in Batman: City of Strange

Score: +2

Giancarlo Esposito

as Hugo Strange in Batman: Wish

Score: +1

Charles Dance

as Carmine Falcone in Batman: Wish

Score: +1

Tim Roth

as Mayor Penguin in Batman: Wish

Score: +1

Will Buie Jr.

as James Gordon Jr in Batman: Wish

Score: +1

Bruce Greenwood

as James Gordon in Batman: Wish

Score: +1

Fedor Steer

as Victor Zsasz in Batman: Wish

Score: +1

James McAvoy

as The Riddler in Batman: Wish

Score: +1

Matthew Lillard

as The Riddler in Batman: Wish

Score: -1

Anson Mount

as The Batman in Batman: Wish

Score: +1

Scott Eastwood

as The Batman in Batman: Wish

Score: -1

Anya Taylor-Joy

as Harley Quinn in Batman: Wish

Score: +1