Suggestions by @jacobtuck

Prince

as Trevor Penick in BoyBand Biopics

Score: -1

Tom Cruise

as Dan Miller in BoyBand Biopics

Score: +1

Wilmer Valderrama

as Erik Michael Estrada in BoyBand Biopics

Score: +1

Drew Lachey

as Nick Lachey in BoyBand Biopics

Score: +1

Nick Lachey

as Drew Lachey in BoyBand Biopics

Score: +1

Richard Marx

as Jeff Timmons in BoyBand Biopics

Score: +1

Moby

as Justin Jeffre in BoyBand Biopics

Score: +1

Bob Dole

as Taylor Hanson in BoyBand Biopics

Score: +1

Jonathan Taylor Thomas

as Zach Hanson in BoyBand Biopics

Score: +2

Ryan Seacrest

as Isaac Hanson in BoyBand Biopics

Score: 0

Ryan Reynolds

as Louis Tomlinson in BoyBand Biopics

Score: +1

Heath Ledger

as Liam Payne in BoyBand Biopics

Score: +1

Mikel Pace

as Niall Horan in BoyBand Biopics

Score: +1

Joe Jonas

as Zayn Malik in BoyBand Biopics

Score: +1

Leonardo DiCaprio

as Harry Styles in BoyBand Biopics

Score: +1

Pauly Shore

as Donnie Whalberg in BoyBand Biopics

Score: +1

Rocky Hamblin

as Danny Wood in BoyBand Biopics

Score: +1

Ellen DeGeneres

as Joey Mac in BoyBand Biopics

Score: +1

Seth MacFarlane

as Jordan Knight in BoyBand Biopics

Score: +1

Mario López

as Jonathan Knight in BoyBand Biopics

Score: +1