Suggestions by @jacobking1
474 suggestions
Martin Landau
as Grima Wormtongue in Lord of the Rings in Classic Hollywood (1950s)
John Gavin
as Officer Martinez in The Batman in Classic Hollywood (1950s)
Edward G. Robinson
as Carmine Falcone in The Batman in Classic Hollywood (1950s)
William Wyler
as Director in The Batman in Classic Hollywood (1950s)
Martin Landau
as Edward Nashton in The Batman in Classic Hollywood (1950s)
Claude Rains
as Alfred Pennyworth in The Batman in Classic Hollywood (1950s)
Woody Strode
as James Gordon in The Batman in Classic Hollywood (1950s)
Jack Warden
as Oswald "Oz" Cobblepot in The Batman in Classic Hollywood (1950s)
James Mason
as Grima Wormtongue in Lord of the Rings in Classic Hollywood (1950s)
Yul Brynner
as Scipio Africanus in The Second Punic War in Classic Hollywood (1960s)
Omar Sharif
as Hannibal in The Second Punic War in Classic Hollywood (1960s)
Hedy Lamarr
as Galadriel in Lord of the Rings in Classic Hollywood (1950s)
Linda Harrison
as Helen of Troy in The Trojan War in Classic Hollywood (1950s)
Boris Karloff
as Saruman in Lord of the Rings in Classic Hollywood (1950s)
Lee Van Cleef
as Grima Wormtongue in Lord of the Rings in Classic Hollywood (1950s)
Celeste Holm
as Penelope in The Trojan War in Classic Hollywood (1950s)
Lee J. Cobb
as Agamemnon in The Trojan War in Classic Hollywood (1950s)
Omar Sharif
as Aeneas in The Trojan War in Classic Hollywood (1950s)
Yul Brynner
as Hector in The Trojan War in Classic Hollywood (1950s)
Laurence Olivier
as Odysseus in The Trojan War in Classic Hollywood (1950s)