Suggestions by @jacobfisher

Kenneth Branagh

as Gordon in The Thomas the Tank Engine Movie(story private)

Score: +2

Colin Firth

as Sir Topham Hat in The Thomas the Tank Engine Movie(story private)

Score: +2

Rupert Grint

as Percy in The Thomas the Tank Engine Movie(story private)

Score: +1

Ewen McGregor

as Duck in The Thomas the Tank Engine Movie(story private)

Score: +2

Richard E. Grant

as The Clergyman/ Wilbery Awdry in The Thomas the Tank Engine Movie(story private)

Score: +2

Nick Frost

as Henry in The Thomas the Tank Engine Movie(story private)

Score: +2

Idris Elba

as Diesel in The Thomas the Tank Engine Movie(story private)

Score: 0

Patrick Stewart

as Edward in The Thomas the Tank Engine Movie(story private)

Score: +2

Karen Gillan

as Emily in The Thomas the Tank Engine Movie(story private)

Score: +1

Andrew Garfield

as Thomas in The Thomas the Tank Engine Movie(story private)

Score: +1

Sam Neill

as Toby in The Thomas the Tank Engine Movie(story private)

Score: +2

Michael Palin

as Toby in The Thomas the Tank Engine Movie(story private)

Score: +2

Harry Styles

as James in The Thomas the Tank Engine Movie(story private)

Score: +2

Marc Forster

as Director in The Thomas the Tank Engine Movie(story private)

Score: +1