Suggestions by @jacobferguson216

Neal McDonough

as Nick Chopper in Cowardly

Score: +1

Maddie Baillio

as Jennyanydots in Cats (2029)

Score: -2

Maddie Dixon-Poirier

as Jennyanydots in Cats (2029)

Score: -1

Meryl Streep

as Grizabella in Cats (2029)

Score: +3

Leslie Odom Jr.

as Macavity in Cats (2029)

Score: +2

Sigourney Weaver

as Old Deuteronomy in Cats (2029)

Score: +4

Tim Curry

as Scrooge in A Christmas Carol

Score: -1

Zendaya

as Bastet in The Secrets of the Immortal Nicholas Flamel

Score: +1

Maddie Ziegler

as Dorothy Gale in Cowardly

Score: +2

Laurie Davidson

as Lion in Cowardly

Score: +1

Tom Holland

as Strawman in Cowardly

Score: +1