Suggestions by @jackwayne21

Caspar Phillipson

as Mayor Quimby in The Simpsons live action movie

Score: +2

Slash

as Otto Mann in The Simpsons live action movie

Score: +2

Juan Diego Botto

as Nick Reveira in The Simpsons live action movie

Score: +1

Tyler Perry

as Dr Julius Hibbert in The Simpsons live action movie

Score: +3

Blake Garrett Rosenthal

as Milhouse Van Houton in The Simpsons live action movie

Score: +2

Andrew Bryniarski

as Sideshow Bob in The Simpsons live action movie

Score: -1

Jack Nicholson

as Herschel Krustofski in The Simpsons live action movie

Score: +2

Joaquin Phoenix

as Herschel Krustofski in The Simpsons live action movie

Score: -2

John Goodman

as Barney Gumble in The Simpsons live action movie

Score: +3

Anthony Mackie

as Carl Carlson in The Simpsons live action movie

Score: +1

Sebastian Stan

as Lenny Leonard in The Simpsons live action movie

Score: +2

Steve Martin

as Grandpa Simpson in The Simpsons live action movie

Score: +1

Theo Stevenson

as Bart Simpson in The Simpsons live action movie

Score: 0

John Goodman

as Homer Simpson in The Simpsons live action movie

Score: +5

Will Smith

as Marty in Madagascar (Live Action)

Score: +1

Crispin Freeman

as Alex in Madagascar (Live Action)

Score: +1

Jonah Hill

as Sandman in Rise of the Guardians (Live Action)

Score: -1

Finn Carr

as Jamie Bennett in Rise of the Guardians (Live Action)

Score: 0

Tom Hiddleston

as Pitch Black in Rise of the Guardians (Live Action)

Score: +4

Hugh Jackman

as E.Aster Bunnymund in Rise of the Guardians (Live Action)

Score: +3