Suggestions by @jackkirker

Benjamin Wadsworth

as Blaine Anderson in Glee Recast

Score: +1

Jonathan Groff

as Carl Howell in Glee Recast

Score: 0

Katy Perry

as Emma Pillsbury in Glee Recast

Score: +1

Erinn Westbrook

as Santana Lopez in Glee Recast

Score: 0

Paul Wesley

as Will Schuester in Glee Recast

Score: +1

Lucky Blue Smith

as Kurt Hummel in Glee Recast

Score: -1

Lizzo

as Mercedes Jones in Glee Recast

Score: +1

Mikkel Jensen

as Finn Hudson in Glee Recast

Score: +1

Lady Gaga

as Shelby Corcoran in Glee Recast

Score: +1

Tom Hughes

as Jesse St. James in Glee Recast

Score: -1

Nina Dobrev

as Marley Rose in Glee Recast

Score: +1

Emma Roberts

as Quinn Fabray in Glee Recast

Score: -1

Taylor Swift

as Holly Holliday in Glee Recast

Score: +1

Lili Reinhart

as Brittany S. Pierce in Glee Recast

Score: +1