Suggestions by @jackcoleman

Kath Soucie

as Squirps in Paper Mario

Judd Hirsch

as Fahr Outpost Mayor in Paper Mario

Harvey Fierstein

as Morton in Paper Mario

Natalie Portman

as Ms. Mowz in Paper Mario

Elsie Fisher

as Mimi in Paper Mario

David Spade

as Bob in Paper Mario

Bill Murray

as Huff N. Puff in Paper Mario

Alison Brie

as Goombella in Paper Mario

Danny McBride

as Tubba Blubba in Paper Mario

Ben Kingsley

as Goomboss in Paper Mario

Mel Brooks

as Kroop in Paper Mario

Michael McKean

as Koopley in Paper Mario

Wanda Sykes

as Birdo in Paper Mario

Seth Green

as Larry in Paper Mario

Chris Pratt

as Mario in Paper Mario

Poofesure

as Reclusa in Mario and Luigi series

Poofesure

as Reclusa in Mario and Luigi series

Jeffrey Tambor

as Great Conductor in Mario and Luigi series

Kristen Schaal

as Toadette in Mario and Luigi series

Richard Horvitz

as Reclusa in Mario and Luigi series