Suggestions by @j_bkr

Paul Rudd

as Jack Ryder in Batman: Arkham City (2003)

Score: +1

Josh Hartnett

as Tim Drake in Batman: Arkham City (2003)

Score: +1

Martin Short

as Jervis Tetch in Batman: Arkham City (2003)

Score: +1

Patrick Stewart

as Victor Fries in Batman: Arkham City (2003)

Score: +1

Steven Blum

as Basil Karlo in Batman: Arkham City (2003)

Score: +1

Julia Stiles

as Barbara Gordon in Batman: Arkham City (2003)

Score: +1

John Cleese

as Alfred Pennyworth in Batman: Arkham City (2003)

Score: +1

Josh Brolin

as Harvey Dent in Batman: Arkham City (2003)

Score: +1

Timothy Spall

as Oswald Cobblepot in Batman: Arkham City (2003)

Score: +1

Cameron Diaz

as Harleen Quinzel in Batman: Arkham City (2003)

Score: +1

Catherine Zeta-Jones

as Talia Al Ghul in Batman: Arkham City (2003)

Score: +1

Charlize Theron

as Selina Kyle in Batman: Arkham City (2003)

Score: +1

Alan Rickman

as Ra's Al Ghul in Batman: Arkham City (2003)

Score: +1

Christopher Lee

as Hugo Strange in Batman: Arkham City (2003)

Score: +1

Willem Dafoe

as Joker in Batman: Arkham City (2003)

Score: +1

Jim Caviezel

as Bruce Wayne in Batman: Arkham City (2003)

Score: +1

Christopher Young

as Composer in Batman: Arkham Asylum (1999)

Score: +1

Paul Dini

as Writer in Batman: Arkham Asylum (1999)

Score: +1

Michael Uslan

as Producer in Batman: Arkham Asylum (1999)

Score: +1

Sam Raimi

as Director in Batman: Arkham Asylum (1999)

Score: +1