Suggestions by @itsgrapes_exe

William Parry

as Captain Edward Smith in Actors by Historical Figures They've Played

Score: +1

Benjamin Rayson

as Charlemagne in Actors by Historical Figures They've Played

Score: +1

Antonio Cipriano

as Racetrack Higgins in Newsies

Score: +1

Alexander Gemignani

as Jean Valjean in Les Mis: The Dream Cast

Score: +1

Anthony Perkins

as Davey Jacobs in Newsies (Vintage Movie Musical)

Score: +1

Christian Borle

as Billy Flynn in Chicago Live

Score: +1

Andrew Rannells

as Leo Bloom in The Producers: Live!

Score: +1

Josh Gad

as Max Bialystock in The Producers: Live!

Score: +1

Leonard Frey

as Elmer in Newsies (Vintage Movie Musical)

Score: +1

David Winters

as Romeo in Newsies (Vintage Movie Musical)

Score: +1

Tucker Smith

as Finch Cortez in Newsies (Vintage Movie Musical)

Score: +1

George Chakiris

as Specs in Newsies (Vintage Movie Musical)

Score: +1

Kelli O'Hara

as Sarah in Company (Musical)

Score: +1

Annaleigh Ashford

as Susan in Company (Musical)

Score: +1

Stephen Bogardus

as Rabbi (Present) in Harmony: A New Musical

Score: +1

Nathan Salstone

as Rabbi (Past) in Harmony: A New Musical

Score: +1

Ben Fankhauser

as Gordon in A New Brain

Score: +1