Suggestions by @itsgrapes_exe

Chip Zien

as Mr. Mushnik in Little Shop of Horrors

Score: +1

Eddie Cooper

as Audrey II in Little Shop of Horrors

Score: +1

Andy Karl

as Orin Scrivello D.D.S. in Little Shop of Horrors

Score: +1

Matthew Duckett

as James Garfield/Ensemble in Assassins

Score: +1

Michael Rupert

as Larry in Company (Musical)

Score: +1

Nathan Salstone

as David Herold/Ensemble in Assassins

Score: +1

Timothy Hughes

as Gerald Ford/Ensemble in Assassins

Score: +1

Raymond Walsh

as Grantaire in Les Mis: The Dream Cast

Score: +1

Ben Fankhauser

as Hunter McNamara in Hunters: The Musical (Genderswap Heathers)

Score: +1

Jeremy Jordan

as Heather Chandler in Heathers: The Musical (Genderswap)

Score: +1

Phil Daniels

as Phil Daniels in Blur (Theatre Edition)

Score: +1

Ben Fankhauser

as Dave Rowntree in Blur (Theatre Edition)

Score: +1

Adam Chanler-Berat

as Graham Coxon in Blur (Theatre Edition)

Score: +1

Aaron Tveit

as Alex James in Blur (Theatre Edition)

Score: +1

Mike Faist

as Mike Joyce in The Smiths (Theatre Edition)

Score: +1

Andrew Rannells

as Craig Gannon in The Smiths (Theatre Edition)

Score: +1

Nathan Salstone

as Johnny Marr in The Smiths (Theatre Edition)

Score: +1

Andrew Keenan-Bolger

as Andy Rourke in The Smiths (Theatre Edition)

Score: +1

Jay Armstrong Johnson

as Morrissey in The Smiths (Theatre Edition)

Score: +1

Jessica Keenan Wynn

as Christine Baranski in Sarah Michelle Gellar Biopic Movie (2023)

Score: +1