Suggestions by @itsascream_baby88

Sebastian Stan

as Cotton Weary in Scream: The Audition (1995)

Score: 0

Liam McIntyre

as Cotton Weary in Scream: The Audition (1995)

Score: 0

Scott Eastwood

as Cotton Weary in Scream: The Audition (1995)

Score: 0

Taron Egerton

as Cotton Weary in Scream: The Audition (1995)

Score: 0

Chris Evans

as Cotton Weary in Scream: The Audition (1995)

Score: +2

David Corenswet

as Cotton Weary in Scream: The Audition (1995)

Score: 0

Nikolaj Coster-Waldau

as Principal Himbry in Scream: The Audition (1995)

Score: +2

Michael Shannon

as Principal Himbry in Scream: The Audition (1995)

Score: 0

Jason Isaacs

as Principal Himbry in Scream: The Audition (1995)

Score: 0

Karl Urban

as Principal Himbry in Scream: The Audition (1995)

Score: 0

Ben Affleck

as Principal Himbry in Scream: The Audition (1995)

Score: 0

Jensen Ackles

as Principal Himbry in Scream: The Audition (1995)

Score: 0

Ethan Hawke

as Principal Himbry in Scream: The Audition (1995)

Score: 0

Misty Lee

as Nancy Loomis in Scream: The Audition (1995)

Score: +2

Kelly Sheridan

as Nancy Loomis in Scream: The Audition (1995)

Score: +2

Hilary Swank

as Nancy Loomis in Scream: The Audition (1995)

Score: +2

Kelly Macdonald

as Nancy Loomis in Scream: The Audition (1995)

Score: +2

Gemma Arterton

as Nancy Loomis in Scream: The Audition (1995)

Score: 0

Tina Fey

as Nancy Loomis in Scream: The Audition (1995)

Score: 0

Olivia Colman

as Nancy Loomis in Scream: The Audition (1995)

Score: 0