Suggestions by @isuraku

Lucas Hedges

as Jason Todd in Red Hood

Score: -1

Robert Pattinson

as Bruce Wayne in Red Hood

Score: +2

Jack Quaid

as Alberto Falcone in Batman: The Long Halloween

Score: +2

Bryan Cranston

as James Gordon in Batman: The Long Halloween

Score: +1

Olivia Wilde

as Selina Kyle in Batman: The Long Halloween

Score: +3

Rory McCann

as Solomon Grundy in Batman: The Long Halloween

Score: +1

Hafþór Júlíus Björnsson

as Solomon Grundy in Batman: The Long Halloween

Score: +2

Matthew McConaughey

as Harvey Dent in Batman: The Long Halloween

Score: +1

Jeremy Irons

as Alfred Pennyworth in Batman: The Long Halloween

Score: -1

Richard E. Grant

as Carmine Falcone in Batman: The Long Halloween

Score: +2

Richard E. Grant

as Alberto Falcone in Batman: The Long Halloween

Score: +1

Alfred Molina

as Julian Gregory Day in Batman: The Long Halloween

Score: +1

Vince Vaughn

as Julian Gregory Day in Batman: The Long Halloween

Score: +2

Zoë Kravitz

as Selina Kyle in Batman: The Long Halloween

Score: 0

Linda Cardellini

as Gilda Dent in Batman: The Long Halloween

Score: +3

Ryan Gosling

as Harvey Dent in Batman: The Long Halloween

Score: -1

Robert Pattinson

as Bruce Wayne in Batman: The Long Halloween

Score: +3