Suggestions by @iskelaofthenight

Charlie Sheen

as Shade in Tales From the Borderlands

Score: +1

Willa Holland

as Athena in Tales From the Borderlands

Score: +1

Michael Jai White

as Finch in Tales From the Borderlands

Score: +1

Louis C.K.

as Rudiger in Tales From the Borderlands

Score: +1

Chris Pratt

as Rhys in Tales From the Borderlands

Score: -3

Aubrey Plaza

as Fiona in Tales From the Borderlands

Score: -2

Sam Rockwell

as Scooter in Tales From the Borderlands

Score: -1

Jaylen Barron

as Sasha in Tales From the Borderlands

Score: 0

Jasika Nicole

as Yvette in Tales From the Borderlands

Score: +1

Dave Bautista

as Brick in Tales From the Borderlands

Score: +3

Donald Sutherland

as Felix in Tales From the Borderlands

Score: +1

Rory McCann

as Tector in Tales From the Borderlands

Score: +1

James Earl Jones

as Cassius in Tales From the Borderlands

Score: +1

Anna Brisbin

as Gortys in Tales From the Borderlands

Score: -2

Anthony Stewart Head

as Henderson in Tales From the Borderlands

Score: +1

Brian Huskey

as Nakayama in Tales From the Borderlands

Score: +1

Nicolas Cage

as Rudiger in Tales From the Borderlands

Score: +1

Keanu Reeves

as Zer0 in Tales From the Borderlands

Score: +3

Brad Pitt

as Kroger in Tales From the Borderlands

Score: +1

Jensen Ackles

as August in Tales From the Borderlands

Score: +1