Suggestions by @isaacreeves2024

Owen Teague

as Peter Thornton in Dexter Original Sin season 2

Score: +1

Reno Wilson

as Bobby Watt in Dexter Original Sin season 2

Score: +1

C. Thomas Howell

as Robert Milson in Dexter Original Sin season 2

Score: +1

Sarah Michelle Gellar

as Tanya Martin in Dexter Original Sin season 2

Score: +1

Sarah Michelle Gellar (Call of Duty Zombies)

as Tanya Martin in Dexter Original Sin season 2

Score: +1

Alex Shimizu

as Vince Masuka in Dexter Original Sin season 2

Score: +1

James Martinez

as Angel Batista in Dexter Original Sin season 2

Score: +1

Molly Brown

as Debra Morgan in Dexter Original Sin season 2

Score: +1

Roby Attal

as Brian Moser in Dexter Original Sin season 2

Score: +1

Christian Slater

as Harry Morgan in Dexter Original Sin season 2

Score: +1

Patrick Gibson

as Dexter Morgan in Dexter Original Sin season 2

Score: +1

Lucas Hedges

as Elliot Budge in Dexter rewrite

Score: +1

Jay Hernandez

as Roberto 'Bobby' Acosta in Dexter rewrite

Score: +1

Tom Cavanagh

as Dr Danco in Dexter rewrite

Score: +1

Armie Hammer

as Kyle Chutsky in Dexter rewrite

Score: +1

Travis Willingham

as The Phantom in Dexter rewrite

Score: +1

Charlotte Rampling

as Dr Vogel in Dexter rewrite

Score: +1

James Remar

as Harry Morgan in Dexter rewrite

Score: +1

Jesse Borrego

as The Skinner in Dexter rewrite

Score: +1

Charlotte Rampling

as Dr. Vogel in Dexter rewrite

Score: +1