Suggestions by @indroves

Barry Keoghan

as Kyle "Jax" Jaxon in Arch Angel

Score: -1

Barry Keoghan

as Tod Lane in Arch Angel

Score: +1

Drew Starkey

as Tod Lane in Arch Angel

Score: +2

Gregg Sulkin

as Kyle "Jax" Jaxon in Arch Angel

Score: -1

Luke Benward

as Colton Christoper in Arch Angel

Score: +1

Drew Starkey

as David Alino in Arch Angel

Score: -1

Blake Jenner

as David Alino in Arch Angel

Score: +2

Gregg Sulkin

as David Alino in Arch Angel

Score: -1

Luke Benward

as David Alino in Arch Angel

Score: -1

Barry Keoghan

as David Alino in Arch Angel

Score: +1

Jack Quaid

as David Alino in Arch Angel

Score: -1

Alexander Ludwig

as David Alino in Arch Angel

Score: +1

Jordan Thoma

as David Alino in Arch Angel

Score: -1

Harris Dickinson

as David Alino in Arch Angel

Score: -2

Noah Centineo

as David Alino in Arch Angel

Score: +1

Shane Harper

as Noel Hudson in Arch Angel

Score: +1

Jace Norman

as Daniel Woodward in High Grail

Score: +1

Luke Mullen

as Daniel Woodward in High Grail

Score: -1

Michael Johnston

as Reese Logan in High Grail

Score: -1

Alex Fitzalan

as Reese Logan in High Grail

Score: -1