Suggestions by @idontgetthis14

Toby Stephens

as Lobo in Superman Reboot

Score: +1

Gilbert Gottfried

as Mxyzptlk in Superman Reboot

Score: +3

Josh Duhamel

as John Corben in Superman Reboot

Score: +1

Tyrese Gibson

as Mongul in Superman Reboot

Score: +3

Andy Serkis

as Raymond Jensen in Superman Reboot

Score: 0

Kevin Michael Richardson

as Uxas in Superman Reboot

Score: +1

Ben Barnes

as Zod in Superman Reboot

Score: +3

Bill Nighy

as Vril Dox in Superman Reboot

Score: +1

Deborah Ann Woll

as Lana Lang in Superman Reboot

Score: +1

Chris Bauer

as Bibbo Bibbowski in Superman Reboot

Score: +1

Pete Davidson

as Jimmy Olsen in Superman Reboot

Score: 0

Sterling K. Brown

as Johnathan Kent in Superman Reboot

Score: +1

Whoopi Goldberg

as Martha Kent in Superman Reboot

Score: +1

Emyri Crutchfield

as Kara Zor-El in Superman Reboot

Score: +2

Billy Zane

as Lex Luthor in Superman Reboot

Score: +1

Alison Brie

as Lois Lane in Superman Reboot

Score: +4

Alison Brie

as Lois Lane in Superman Reboot

Score: +1

Felicity Jones

as Lois Lane in Superman

Score: +9

William Jackson Harper

as Clark Kent in Superman Reboot

Score: -3